Books About Submission
A guy I read just posted a list of books about leadership, male headship and submission.
- Recovering Biblical Manhood & Womanhood (John Piper & Wayne Grudem)
- Love & Respect: The Love She Most Desires, The Respect He Desperately Needs (Emerson Eggerichs)
- This Momentary Marriage: A Parable of Permanence (John Piper)
- Rocking the Roles (Robert Lewis)
And my bullshit detector went off because I couldn’t help but think, “It’s kind of convenient that all the book about submission are written by guys?” If I remember Eden correctly, doesn’t it say something about, “And he will rule over you,” being part of the curse. In other words, “IT’S NOT A GOOD THING.”
Jon
“If I remember Eden correctly, doesn’t it say something about, “And he will rule over you,” being part of the curse. In other words, “IT’S NOT A GOOD THING.”
Good Point
Jon
“If I remember Eden correctly, doesn’t it say something about, “And he will rule over you,” being part of the curse. In other words, “IT’S NOT A GOOD THING.”
Good Point
sonja n a
Yeah … books about being submissive that are written by women are pretty scarce … like hen's teeth. Kinda funny (not haha).
sonja n a
Yeah … books about being submissive that are written by women are pretty scarce … like hen's teeth. Kinda funny (not haha).
makeesha
Yeah, I point that out ALL THE TIME. That if we are “redeemed from the curse”, part of that redemption is from male domination.
makeesha
Yeah, I point that out ALL THE TIME. That if we are “redeemed from the curse”, part of that redemption is from male domination.
Theresa Seeber
Yeah, I always thought it odd that part of the curse would be that her desire would be for her husband. LOL It pisses me off when I am frustrated with my husband that I can turn around not long after and find him really attractive in some way.
Theresa Seeber
Yeah, I always thought it odd that part of the curse would be that her desire would be for her husband. LOL It pisses me off when I am frustrated with my husband that I can turn around not long after and find him really attractive in some way.
Tyler Braun
K try reading this one then:
Hunt, Susan, Peggy Hutcheson. Leadership for Women in the Church.
Tyler Braun
K try reading this one then:
Hunt, Susan, Peggy Hutcheson. Leadership for Women in the Church.
Eric
While I'm sure my position on this topic is a lot closer to yours than to those authors, I have to say I'm a little disappointed in your “critique” of them. Anybody who is at all familiar with their position would know it's silly to suggest that they think “And he will rule over you” is a “GOOD THING.”
The problem with bullshit detectors (I've found) is that they tend to stop us from even taking the time to understand what others are saying.
Eric
While I'm sure my position on this topic is a lot closer to yours than to those authors, I have to say I'm a little disappointed in your “critique” of them. Anybody who is at all familiar with their position would know it's silly to suggest that they think “And he will rule over you” is a “GOOD THING.”
The problem with bullshit detectors (I've found) is that they tend to stop us from even taking the time to understand what others are saying.
sarooney
My initial reaction to the titles: double puke.
Unfortunately, there *are* books by women promoting the 'male headship' weirdness. That's always seemed tragic to me – women encouraging other women into such dysfunction.
sarooney
My initial reaction to the titles: double puke.
Unfortunately, there *are* books by women promoting the 'male headship' weirdness. That's always seemed tragic to me – women encouraging other women into such dysfunction.
julieglavic
We were recently discussing this curse in a class, and the professor (a woman) asked whether we thought the curse was prescriptive (a good thing we shouldn't try to “get out of”) or descriptive (a description of the consequences of the fall, which we ought to reverse/redeem). One student suggested that the curse is prescriptive because women still feel pain in childbirth.
The professor said, “But would you try to soothe that pain, through medicine or otherwise?”
Student: “Well, of course.”
The professor replied, “For the birth of my first child, we were living in a remote village in Alaska. There was only one doctor in the town. I thought I'd do the natural birth thing, no medicine, but 16 hours into labor, I realized that God made people who made medicines for a reason. So I told the doctor, 'Hey, it's been 16 hours and I'm thinking it's time for some painkillers.'
He said, 'Nope. Genesis 3.'
I'll give him this: He was consistent in his views.”
This story made me so angry that I almost punched my desk sitting there in the classroom. Even most “complementarians” agree that medical care for women with difficult childbirth is important – the number of women without medical care who die in childbirth is horrifying. But if the curse-as-prescriptive view is carried out consistently, we get these stories and worse.
julieglavic
We were recently discussing this curse in a class, and the professor (a woman) asked whether we thought the curse was prescriptive (a good thing we shouldn't try to “get out of”) or descriptive (a description of the consequences of the fall, which we ought to reverse/redeem). One student suggested that the curse is prescriptive because women still feel pain in childbirth.
The professor said, “But would you try to soothe that pain, through medicine or otherwise?”
Student: “Well, of course.”
The professor replied, “For the birth of my first child, we were living in a remote village in Alaska. There was only one doctor in the town. I thought I'd do the natural birth thing, no medicine, but 16 hours into labor, I realized that God made people who made medicines for a reason. So I told the doctor, 'Hey, it's been 16 hours and I'm thinking it's time for some painkillers.'
He said, 'Nope. Genesis 3.'
I'll give him this: He was consistent in his views.”
This story made me so angry that I almost punched my desk sitting there in the classroom. Even most “complementarians” agree that medical care for women with difficult childbirth is important – the number of women without medical care who die in childbirth is horrifying. But if the curse-as-prescriptive view is carried out consistently, we get these stories and worse.
Anonymous
We were recently discussing this curse in a class, and the professor (a woman) asked whether we thought the curse was prescriptive (a good thing we shouldn’t try to “get out of”) or descriptive (a description of the consequences of the fall, which we ought to reverse/redeem). One student suggested that the curse is prescriptive because women still feel pain in childbirth. rnrnThe professor said, “But would you try to soothe that pain, through medicine or otherwise?”rnrnStudent: “Well, of course.”rnrnThe professor replied, “For the birth of my first child, we were living in a remote village in Alaska. There was only one doctor in the town. I thought I’d do the natural birth thing, no medicine, but 16 hours into labor, I realized that God made people who made medicines for a reason. So I told the doctor, ‘Hey, it’s been 16 hours and I’m thinking it’s time for some painkillers.’rnrnHe said, ‘Nope. Genesis 3.’rnrnI’ll give him this: He was consistent in his views.” rnrnThis story made me so angry that I almost punched my desk sitting there in the classroom. Even most “complementarians” agree that medical care for women with difficult childbirth is important – the number of women without medical care who die in childbirth is horrifying. But if the curse-as-prescriptive view is carried out consistently, we get these stories and worse.
Jonathan Brink
But Eric, the very nature of the arguments, of which I grew up in and are very familiar is a form of rule.
Jonathan Brink
But Eric, the very nature of the arguments, of which I grew up in and are very familiar is a form of rule.
Jonathan Brink
Julie, while I won't go into it here I think most of the church gets the curses completely wrong. And it is important to note that the pain in childbearing (its not birth) is actually given by God, which means it has a redemptive purpose.
Jonathan Brink
Julie, while I won't go into it here I think most of the church gets the curses completely wrong. And it is important to note that the pain in childbearing (its not birth) is actually given by God, which means it has a redemptive purpose.
Eric
That could be … I don't who you grew up with.
But Piper, for sure, recognizes that “And he will rule over you” is a curse. He says “It is a description of misery, not a model for marriage.”
Eric
That could be … I don't who you grew up with.
But Piper, for sure, recognizes that “And he will rule over you” is a curse. He says “It is a description of misery, not a model for marriage.”
Jonathan Brink
But Eric, the very nature of the arguments, of which I grew up in and are very familiar is a form of rule.
Jonathan Brink
Julie, while I won’t go into it here I think most of the church gets the curses completely wrong. And it is important to note that the pain in childbearing (its not birth) is actually given by God, which means it has a redemptive purpose.
Eric
That could be … I don’t who you grew up with. rnrnBut Piper, for sure, recognizes that “And he will rule over you” is a curse. He says “It is a description of misery, not a model for marriage.”